This casserole won my husband’s heart over when we were dating. Well, I think our relationship was a little more complicated than that…but he did love Cheesy Chicken Casserole then and still asks for it today 14 happily-married years later!
Cheesy Chicken Casserole is just one of those simple, comfort food casseroles that delivers every time. The question I had, though, is could I make this traditionally processed food-laden dish a bit healthier without sacrificing taste or convenience? Can “real food meet reality”, as our Recipe Index tagline says?
Well, yes, I think so! In this Cheesy Chicken Casserole recipe, I simply made a few swaps to clean up the junk in the original recipe I made 14 years ago.
Chicken breasts: Buy Bare Chicken or organic chicken, to avoid added antibiotics and preservatives.
Canned Cream of Mushroom Soup: Campbell’s or other standard canned “cream of” soups are one of the worst convenience items you can buy. Read the ingredient label sometime and see if you can determine what most of the items listed are. It’s not real food, that’s for sure. So, I always spend a little more and substitute with an organic soup, preferably in a box or BPA-free can. You can also certainly make your own, too!
Stuffing: Store-bought stuffing mix is also filled with processed ingredients, preservatives, and additives. To avoid those, spend a little more and purchase an organic (and preferably whole wheat) stuffing in the health food section. Or, again, make your own! I also add in a little ground flaxseed or chia seed to up the nutrition.
Butter: I love real butter, especially organic, grass-fed butter. But, I did cut back on how much is used in this recipe. You could also substitute olive oil instead, if you want.
I feel like a broken record, but be sure to divide this in half and freeze one for later. (Freezer cooking changes the way I think about every meal nowadays.) Or double and freeze several for later! Freezer meal instructions are included below.
BONUS: Use up leftover turkey and stuffing from Thanksgiving in this simple casserole.
Did I mention it’s easy to make? Check out these simple steps and be sure to pin this image for later use.
Prep Time:
Yield:
Print
PinDescription
A healthier version of the simple, comfort food classic that delivers every time!
Ingredients
- 6 chicken breasts, diced
- 1 can/small box (15 ounces) organic cream of mushroom or cream of chicken soup
- 2 cups cheddar cheese, shredded
- 6 ounces stuffing mix
- 1/4 cup ground flaxseed or ground chia seeds
- 1/3 cup water
- 4 tablespoons butter, melted
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Grease a 9×13 casserole pan with cooking spray.
- Spread diced chicken over the bottom of the pan.
- Top chicken with cream soup evenly.
- Sprinkle cheese evenly over the casserole.
- In a bowl, mix stuffing, flax/chia, water, and butter. Spread over the top of the casserole.
- Bake uncovered for 40-45 minutes or until chicken is done (white throughout) and corners are bubbly.
Notes
Freezer Meal Instructions:
Put casserole together and freeze it before baking. When you’re ready to cook it, let thaw in the fridge over night. If it’s still slightly frozen in the middle, you’ll just have to cook it longer than the recipe calls for or defrost a bit in the microwave before baking. Cover it with foil if the top gets too brown in the oven.
I just discovered this recipe and love that it can be frozen. I have baby #4 coming at the beginning of February so trying to get prepared! Would you mind telling me what stuffing you use when you don’t just make it yourself? Thanks so much!
Just try to find one with the fewest ingredients. 🙂
Is the soup you use condensed, and if so, do you prepare it with water prior to use in the recipe? Thanks!
It is condensed and I don’t mix with the water first. I hope that helps!
Good flavor
★★★★
Thanks for the review, Jennifer!
Is the chicken raw when you put it in?
Yep! I just updated the recipe to clarify that. Thanks!
Can I use black chia seeds instead of ground chia seeds? I think black chia seeds are considered “whole” chia seeds. Would this work?
Hmmm, I don’t think I use chia seeds in this one. But, hey, good idea. Why not? 🙂
Hi,
This sounds delicious but I was wondering if you have a recommendation to replace the cream of mushroom. I can’t eat them but would love to make this!
Thanks!
If mushrooms are the problem, you can definitely use Cream of Chicken or Cream of Celery soups.
Do you eat this on it’s own or served with something? What can it be served with?
The great thing about this casserole is that it’s a pretty complete meal–meat, grain, vegetables, cheese. But, I usually serve it with a few other sides like a simple baguette, green salad, and cut up fruit.
Rachel and/or Polly,
What container do you use to freeze your meals? I used to buy Gladware 8 x 8 containers, but now I can only find them in 9 x 13 size. The 9 x 13 is too big for most of what I freeze. I have been watching the internet for several months and they are “out of stock” everywhere. I really like these containers, and would like to find more. Do you have any suggestions?
Thanks,
Nancy Tran
Hi Nancy! We wrote all about the containers we most prefer in this post. https://thrivinghomeblog.com/healthy-recipes-index/healthy-freezer-meals-recipes/
I may be overlooking them, but I’m not seeing freezer directions.
Thanks!
Thanks, I’ll get this recipe updated!